Similac vs Enfamil — Which Milk Formula Is Best For Your Baby?

Both baby formulas are top leading options, and their differences aren’t far cry from each other. Like most products, the Similac and Enfamil milk formulas are giving mothers a difficulty in choosing what’s best for their babies.

That is, and as expected, online reviews only make things worse, coz every mom out there is ready to strongly vouch for either of the products. For a new mom, this can be really confusing and thus you might yourself caught between stools on which milk formula to opt for.

Nonetheless, you shouldn’t worry because, by the time you’re finished reading this review, you’ll know exactly what product (either Similac or Emfamil) to choose.  

Similac vs. Enfamil

Is There A Difference In Ingredients? 

When considering the list of components, the two products are somewhat the same. Both strive to have a similar protein ratio to that of breast milk. Since the FDA has set its standards on baby formulas, the two products contain similar nutrient density.

However, they do have minuscule distinction. For instance, the Similac derives its nutrients from oleic safflower oil, coconut and soy. On the other hand, the Emfamil derives its milk composition from lactoferrin (a multifunctional protein), and from MFGM (milk fat globule membrane) which supports a child’s cognitive development. Also, MFGM helps with a child’s immune system.  

Although both formulas derive their components from different sources, their effectiveness is the same. For both Similac and Emfamil, their main objective isn’t focused on profits, but on providing healthy products to mothers.

For that reason, despite Similac’s source of oleic safflower and Emfamil’s source of lactoferrin, both products make sure the milk formula contains enough iron. The intention is to have a formula that’s similar to the composition of the natural break milk. 

How Effective Is Either Product?

Babies taking either Similac or Emfamil are risk-free from developing iron-deficiency anaemia, and that they usually have strong bones. So, either way, both milk formulas are safe for your baby.

The only difference is that each baby might react differently from either Emfamil or Similac. That is, every baby is different. While one baby may experience discomfort with Similac, the same baby may find Emfamil very comforting.

Thereby, it’s highly advisable to start with either Similac and then switch to Emfamil based on how the baby reacts to the formula.   

What if neither Emfamil or Similac works with your baby? Well, it’s recommendable to seek assistance from your pediatrician.

Final Thoughts

When picking the right baby formula, it’s important to get both brands and test them out. Check out how your baby reacts to either, and settle on the right formula. Remember, both formulas have similar nutrient density, thanks to the FDA requirements.

Although every mother is ready to go the whole nine yards to defend either the Similac or Emfamil, it’s important to acknowledge that babies are different and they react differently to different milk formulas.

It’s a no brainer that if one brand were better than the other, then the less preferable one would have been out of business. But since both brands are still existing, it means they offer somewhat indistinguishable effects.

Leave a Comment